Kylebooker Fishpond Blue River Chest/Lumbar Pack vs. Orvis & Redington: A Comprehensive Comparison
For avid anglers, choosing the right gear storage is just as important as selecting the right rod and reel. The Kylebooker Fishpond Blue River Chest/Lumbar Pack has gained attention among fly fishermen, but how does it compare to similar offerings from Orvis and Redington? In this review, we’ll analyze their features, durability, comfort, and overall value to determine which pack offers the best performance and cost-effectiveness.
Design & Functionality
Fishpond Blue River Pack
The Kylebooker Fishpond Blue River Pack is a versatile chest/lumbar pack designed for convenience and accessibility. It features:
– Convertible design (can be worn as a chest or lumbar pack)
– Water-resistant materials (made from recycled fabrics)
– Multiple storage compartments (including a large main pocket, smaller accessory pockets, and a built-in fly patch)
– Magnetic closures for quick access
– Adjustable straps for a secure fit
This pack excels in organization, making it easy to carry tippets, flies, leaders, and other essentials without bulkiness.
Orvis Pro Chest Pack
Orvis is known for high-end fly-fishing gear, and their Pro Chest Pack is no exception. Key features include:
– Durable, waterproof construction (Cordura fabric)
– Modular attachment system (compatible with Orvis sling packs)
– Ergonomic design (minimizes shoulder strain)
– Ample storage (zippered pockets, D-ring attachments, and a removable foam fly patch)
While the Orvis pack is well-built, it tends to be pricier than the Fishpond model.
Redington Crosswater Chest Pack
Redington offers a more budget-friendly option with the Crosswater Chest Pack, which includes:
– Lightweight, water-resistant fabric
– Basic storage compartments (two main pockets and a small front organizer)
– Adjustable sternum strap (for stability)
– Affordable price point
However, it lacks the premium materials and modularity of Fishpond and Orvis.
Durability & Comfort
– Fishpond’s Blue River Pack stands out for its eco-friendly yet rugged construction, with reinforced stitching and high-quality zippers. The lumbar option is especially comfortable for long hikes.
– Orvis’s Pro Chest Pack is slightly heavier but offers superior weather resistance, making it ideal for harsh conditions.
– Redington’s Crosswater Pack is decent for casual anglers but may not hold up as well under heavy use.
Price & Value
– Fishpond Blue River Pack: Mid-range price (~$120-$150), offering great balance between quality and cost.
– Orvis Pro Chest Pack: Higher-end (~$180-$220), best for anglers who prioritize premium materials and brand reputation.
– Redington Crosswater Pack: Budget-friendly (~$60-$90), suitable for beginners or occasional use.
Final Verdict: Which One Should You Buy?
– Best Overall Value: Fishpond Blue River Pack – Excellent durability, smart storage, and eco-conscious design at a reasonable price.
– Best Premium Option: Orvis Pro Chest Pack – Superior waterproofing and modularity, but at a higher cost.
– Best Budget Pick: Redington Crosswater Pack – A solid entry-level choice, though less durable than the others.
If you want a high-performing, versatile pack without overspending, the Kylebooker Fishpond Blue River Chest/Lumbar Pack is the best investment among the three. However, if budget is no concern, the Orvis Pro Chest Pack is a top-tier alternative.
Would you like recommendations on additional accessories to pair with these packs? Let me know your fishing style, and I can suggest the best gear combinations! 🎣